Marriage Retreats Pastor & Ministry Leader Retreats Marriage Discipleship Marriage Intensives

Our website uses cookies to enhance the user experience. Review WinShape's privacy policy here.

homemade low country boil, one of our 10 nontraditional christmas dinner ideas

10 Nontraditional Christmas Dinner Ideas for Couples

December 5, 2025

Try Something Different for Dinner This Christmas

Thanksgiving has come and gone, and so has the turkey and dressing, in your opinion. If you and your spouse are planning to host Christmas dinner for your family or friends during this holiday season, consider opting for a nontraditional Christmas dinner. We’ve got ideas for various nontraditional Christmas dinners below—perfect for any time during the month of December, for small or large gatherings, or for enjoying a special night at home with your spouse.

1. Italian

Bruschetta, spaghetti and meatballs, and tiramisu for dessert—it’ll be a cozy, heartwarming, and nontraditional Christmas dinner.

homemade bruschetta, one of our 10 nontraditional christmas dinner ideas

2. Barbecue

This is a great happy medium because you still get some of your favorite traditional sides like macaroni and cheese and green beans, but you pair them with pulled pork, brisket, and barbecue ribs making it a nontraditional Christmas dinner idea.

3. Soup

Make your life easy with a one-pot or Crock-Pot meal. Whip up your favorite homemade chicken noodle soup, vegetable soup, or buffalo chicken soup recipe for the ultimate comfort meal and easy cleanup.

4. Tex-Mex

Honestly, would anyone turn down chips, guacamole and queso, a build-your-own taco bar, and churros for dessert?

homemade fish tacos, one of our 10 nontraditional christmas dinner ideas

5. Breakfast for Dinner 

Pull out all the stops for an elaborate breakfast for dinner display—French toast, eggs, bacon, sausage, pancakes, biscuits, gravy, yogurt, fruit, orange juice, you name it, you make it. And, you’ll have leftovers for Christmas morning breakfast if you make this nontraditional Christmas dinner on Christmas Eve, for example. 

6. Appetizers 

This is a perfect potluck option because each guest can bring their favorite small appetizer—fruit tray, veggie tray, cheese, meatballs, chips and dip, pigs in a blanket, etc. 

7. Roast Beef 

Like above, you don’t have to get super creative if you’re looking for a nontraditional Christmas dinner idea. Just swap proteins from turkey and ham to a tender roast beef! Serve with mashed potatoes and gravy, salad, and rolls, and you’ll be set. 

homemade roast beef, one of our 10 nontraditional christmas dinner ideas

8. Low Country Boil

Try your hand at this one-pot Southern seafood feast. It can be a labor of love but the reward is a delicious smattering of shrimp, sausage, corn, and potatoes, seasoned perfectly. Serve it with melted butter and cocktail sauce and this will be a Christmas dinner you won’t forget.

9. Seafood

Moving along with the seafood theme, skip the turkey and swap your main protein for a fancy seafood option—crab legs, fresh fish, sautéed scallops. Bring the ocean to your landlocked home this Christmas.

10. Pizza

It’ll be like, “Home Alone!” What’s better (and easier for mom and dad) than having a pizza party? Order your favorite pizza or create your own pizzas at home!

homemade pizza, one of our 10 nontraditional christmas dinner ideas

Want More Good Food Without the Hassle? Visit WinShape!

Attend a WinShape Marriage Retreat in the new year, where your marriage will be blessed and your belly will be fully of deliciously curated meals at every turn.

Get Marriage Resources Sent to Your Inbox